Yet in assuming that the brain is a privileged object, neuroscience contradicts itself.
” The brain’s inability to understand the brain is a profound dilemma that isn’t solved through biology. But neuroscientists insist that biology holds the key to everything about the mind. In fact, most of them firmly believe that Brain = Mind. The promise that brain biology is sufficient to explain mind, morality, religion, metaphysics, thinking, feeling, creativity, and so on is empty. So how can we become smarter than our brains? If biology is a dead end, what path to understanding will get past biology? The first step is to acknowledge that the brain isn’t a privileged object.
It isn’t the source of the mind any more than a radio is the source of Mozart and Beethoven. The brain, like a radio, is a receiver. The reason the brain doesn’t know that it is a receiver–aside from the fact that it doesn’t know anything about itself–is that it is too involved in the reception. When thoughts, feelings, sensations, and images fill our minds, we are creatures of experience, enveloped by those experiences. The second step is to clearly define the question: “How do we know what we know?” The only viable way to begin to find the correct answers is to concede something very basic: All knowledge comes from experience, and all experience is in consciousness.
Neuroscience resists such an answer because it goes beyond biology, yet the subject of the brain always did go beyond biology, into philosophy, psychology, and metaphysics. Trying to fence the mind inside the confines of the brain’s apparatus was never valid to begin with. The problem of the mind is a human problem, not a neuroscience problem. All knowledge comes from experience and all experience is in consciousness. Thoughts, memories and our experience of a universe in space-time are all conscious phenomena.
If you agree on this, then to truly understand the mind, you must abandon the brain entirely from its privileged position, demoting it to the lump of atoms and molecules that it actually is. You have now freed the mind from any dependence whatsoever on the brain. Mozart lived before the radio and didn’t depend upon it to create music. The mind existed before the brain and isn’t dependent upon it to create thoughts. Explaining the mind without the brain is unthinkable in the present context of scientists–but it will happen.